Vote up the best first-person shooters set in World War II, and vote down any releases you feel shouldn't make the cut. Most divisive: Mafia II. Setting a new standard in the FPS genre, Call of Duty 2 immerses players in a visceral, cinematic experience spanning four storylines and multiple protagonists across North Africa, Russia, and Europe.

From the fantastical and creative to the grounded and all too human, the second world war has graced the FPS genre many times over with a wide range of titles. The best of these titles are the ones...