Ana Dumaraog of ScreenRant gives it a 9 out of 10, noting that the first two episodes are surprisingly emotional despite the show’s switch to multi-cam. Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage is a worthy replacement for Young Sheldon, Dumaraog says:

In order for the show to work, Sheldon Cooper — whether it's Jim Parsons or Iain Armitage — can't be in the picture if Big Bang Theory lore counts.

"I like laughin' shows," Georgie Cooper (Montana Jordan) declares in the opening scene of "Georgie & Mandy's First Marriage." "Some shows you can hear people laughin', and some you can't. ‘The Wonder Years' - no one's laughin'.